If you only try one pizza, get the pepperoncini with garlic and chicken.
Holy-Shmoly!
Their pizza is very good.

We ordered online for delivery..... Fast delivery and the food was great! Their meatball subs are so good. As was... read moreWe ordered online for delivery..... Fast delivery and the food was great! Their meatball subs are so good. As was everything else we ordered! Really looking forward to the next time we order out. read less

I have eaten several times at NYPO and have yet to be disappointed. My absolute favorite is the Philly Cheesesteak... read moreI have eaten several times at NYPO and have yet to be disappointed. My absolute favorite is the Philly Cheesesteak pizza. The subs are pretty good. I will say the bread leaves a lot to be desired but the amount of meat and toppings they put on make up for it. I haven't had any issues with delivery or take out. I'd say it's better than Zachary's and Three Brothers hands down. read less

Favorite pizza in Chittenden county. Great sauce and crust, cooked to perfection. Friendly and prompt staff. New owners have done... read moreFavorite pizza in Chittenden county. Great sauce and crust, cooked to perfection. Friendly and prompt staff. New owners have done a great job with quality of food. NYPO rules. read less

Pizza to go The thin crust pizza is very good,add the toppins of your choice, get asalad to go with it, very good... read moreThe thin crust pizza is very good,add the toppins of your choice, get asalad to go with it, very good for a quick dinner read less

I swear every time I order is better than the previous.. Never a bad pie or sandwich. The only... read moreI swear every time I order is better than the previous.. Never a bad pie or sandwich. The only place I get pizza from, Devon is amazing and so are his pizza's, Joseph is so polite when ordering. Those boys know their business..
Donna C.
Colchester read less

I'm a really picky eater and I think this place is great. Their sandwiches and subs are great. Everything is... read moreI'm a really picky eater and I think this place is great. Their sandwiches and subs are great. Everything is really fresh- ten times better than a subway sandwich. The pizzas are a great size for the price you pay and great quality. And the best part is they deliver to my house and I live in winooski! I would recommend this place to anyone. read less

Love the stromboli! Always arrives hot and its big enough for two people or two meals.

Amazing Pizza Margarita pizza was so fresh and tasty! My daughter had the wings which she said were the best she ever... read moreMargarita pizza was so fresh and tasty! My daughter had the wings which she said were the best she ever had.
Staff was friendly and attentive. I love this place! read less

We absolutely love NYPO! Tonight we got pizza and wings delivered and both were excellent. We've ordered many times from... read moreWe absolutely love NYPO! Tonight we got pizza and wings delivered and both were excellent. We've ordered many times from them over the past 1.5 years and find them to be great overall. read less

Although we had a bad experience with the employees at the store themselves, the owner was very willing to fix... read moreAlthough we had a bad experience with the employees at the store themselves, the owner was very willing to fix the problem and make sure our next experience isn't like the last. And we will give them a try and review from that point. Thanks again John.
(Our food was fine and has been but the bread was stale and it will be fixed) read less

Ordered 2 turkey subs that were great, and 2 brownies that are huge! Food was great just what I was... read moreOrdered 2 turkey subs that were great, and 2 brownies that are huge! Food was great just what I was looking for. Had our food delivered to the starlight inn and was delivered right on time right to our hotel door. It was nice to be able to order online and have it delivered. Great job thank you! read less

Great local pizzeria! We stopped by for lunch and had a most excellent couple of pies. Outstanding crust, and the sausage and cheese... read moreWe stopped by for lunch and had a most excellent couple of pies. Outstanding crust, and the sausage and cheese pizza was particularly great. The sweet italian sausage was especially good. read less

Always can count on Nypo to be consistent and fairly quick with delivery! Their calzones are delicious and very big.... read moreAlways can count on Nypo to be consistent and fairly quick with delivery! Their calzones are delicious and very big. The boneless and bone in wings are great as well. I recommend their kickin bbq sauce! read less