We deliver daily starting at 11:30am

$15 minimum

Welcome to

New York Pizza Oven

Best Pizza in Colchester Vermont

New York Pizza Oven | Eat Fresh. Eat Local. Eat NYPO!

We’re conveniently located in the heart of Malletts Bay. Locally owned since 2011 by two lifetime friends and lifelong residents of Colchester that share a few of the same basic principles – To serve delicious food, handcrafted pizza, and to treat everyone that walks through the door like family. We have a commitment to quality in everything we do, whether it’s for delivery, pick up, or dine in, come see what sets NYPO apart from the rest. Supporters of our local community and fundraising events – Eat Fresh, Eat Local, Eat NYPO!

Testimonials

  • 5 star ratingWe absolutely love NYPO! Tonight we got pizza and wings delivered and both were excellent. We've ordered many times from... read more

    Mayte G. Avatar
    Mayte G.
    7/08/2017

    5 star ratingGreat local pizzeria! We stopped by for lunch and had a most excellent couple of pies. Outstanding crust, and the sausage and cheese... read more

    Lisa B Avatar
    Lisa B
    8/16/2015

    5 star ratingAmazing Pizza Margarita pizza was so fresh and tasty! My daughter had the wings which she said were the best she ever... read more

    BrodyLynx Avatar
    BrodyLynx
    3/25/2016
  • 5 star ratingAlthough we had a bad experience with the employees at the store themselves, the owner was very willing to fix... read more

    Nicole L. Avatar
    Nicole L.
    10/10/2017

    5 star ratingFavorite pizza in Chittenden county. Great sauce and crust, cooked to perfection. Friendly and prompt staff. New owners have done... read more

    Jim C. Avatar
    Jim C.
    12/20/2011

    5 star ratingI'm a really picky eater and I think this place is great. Their sandwiches and subs are great. Everything is... read more

    Jessie A. Avatar
    Jessie A.
    2/20/2012
  • 5 star ratingPizza to go The thin crust pizza is very good,add the toppins of your choice, get asalad to go with it, very good... read more

    suebreble Avatar
    suebreble
    10/27/2015

    5 star ratingI have eaten several times at NYPO and have yet to be disappointed. My absolute favorite is the Philly Cheesesteak... read more

    J C. Avatar
    J C.
    12/29/2018

    5 star ratingLove the stromboli! Always arrives hot and its big enough for two people or two meals.

    Sara Q. Avatar
    Sara Q.
    3/26/2020

App, Tap, Order!

To make ordering easier & faster we’ve created our own mobile app. Now you can place orders anytime & anywhere ! Get our app for your device now!